What Else In Wuhan? Suspected Cases In COVID-19 Epidemic Database Of China

novel coronavirus covid 19

With cases reported from over 100 countries, corona virus disease of 2019 (covid-19) is a pandemic now.  The disease is caused by the virus called SARS-Cov-2, which is thought to have jumped from the flying mammal bats, sold at the illegal wildlife market inside the Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan, the capital city of Hubei Province in South Central China. However, the first two cases detected during the first week of December 2019 did not report any connection with the market.  Wuhan has a population of 11 million is a second tier high tech city of China, which has several universities and science institutions. Wuhan is one of the first pilot cities of the 5G network in China, where 300 base stations achieved full 5G signal coverage on 1 Nov 2019.

Due to the high infection rate, the city was locked out on 23 Jan 2020.  Before that, about five million people had moved out to other provinces and countries.  These people and the visitors from other places to Wuhan are thought to have spread the virus to other parts of the world.

The statistics of infection in Wuhan, Hubei-less-Wuhan and China-less-Hubei and South Korea are given in table below.  Attack rate is the number of people infected among a million population within the city or the province.  Death rate shows the percentages of patients died.

Epidemiology of Covid-19 in Mainland China as on 16 Feb 2020

Place Date Population Cases Death Attack Rate Death Rate
Wuhan, 15-Feb 11 24509 1245 2228 5.1
Hubei 15-Feb 48 15218 382 317 2.5
China less Hubei 15-Feb 1355 12261 72 9 0.6
National 15-Feb 1403 51988 1699 37 3.3


As the table shows 47% of the patients are from Wuhan, 29% are from Hubei-less-Wuhan and 24% from the rest of China.  When we look at the attack rate, 2228 per million people (or 2.2 per 1000) were affected in Wuhan, as against 317 in Hubei and 9 persons per million in China.

As of 8 March 2020, South Korea has reported 7134 cases and 50 deaths.

The death rate is 5.1% in Wuhan, 2.5% in Hubei and 0.6% in rest of China.  The death rate in S Korea is 0.7% which is similar to China-less Hubei. Wuhan has 0.8% of China’s population, 47% of the cases and 73% of the coronavirus linked deaths in China.

There are about 1400 million people in China, every year some 10 million people die there.  As of 08 March 2020, death of 3100 people has been linked to covi-19.  During the sixty days these deaths have occurred, 1.6 million people have died due to natural causes in China.  The deaths attributed to the virus are 0.12% of the total death during the period.

The following excerpts from the Report of the WHO-China Joint Mission on Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) are reassuring:

Approximately 80% of laboratory confirmed patients have had mild to moderate disease.

Individuals at highest risk for severe disease and death include people aged over 60 years and those with underlying conditions such as hypertension, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, chronic respiratory disease and cancer.

Disease in children appears to be relatively rare and mild with approximately 2.4% of the total reported cases amongst individuals aged less than 19 years.

A very small proportion of those aged under 19 years have developed severe (2.5%) or critical disease.

Mortality increases with age, with the highest mortality among people over 80 years of age.

The median time from onset to clinical recovery for mild cases is approximately 2 weeks and is 3-6 weeks for patients with severe or critical disease. Among patients who have died, the time from symptom onset to outcome ranges from 2-8 weeks.

Kerala’s population is 35 million.  Under the assumption of an attack rate of 100 and death rate of 1%, there will be 3500 infected persons, of whom 350 would be serious, requiring hospitalization and 35 patients would die.   If the attack rate and death rate is assumed to be 300 and 3%, about 10,000 people will be positive to the virus, and about 300 people would die.

In Kerala in 2018, 45000 people were injured in road accidents, 4300 of them died

Contamination of the Database

Why did I use 15 Feb 2020 as the cut off date for China and 8 March for the rest of the world?

The World Health Organization (WHO) definitions of confirmed and probable cases of covid-19 are reproduced below:

Confirmed case:  A person with laboratory confirmation of COVID-19 infection, irrespective of clinical signs and symptoms

Probable case:   A suspect case for which testing for COVID-19 is inconclusive. • Inconclusive being the result of the test reported by the laboratory.

In Wuhan, there was large number of people with symptoms similar to that of covid-19.  As the tests of repeated nucleic acid test were negative, this group of patients were placed in the category of suspected cases till 11 Feb 2020.  During 12-15 Feb, the National health Commission (NHC) included 17410 suspected cases from Wuhan in the confirmed category.

WHO has been publishing the daily numbers of infections and deaths ever since the outbreak.  Until 16th of February, WHO did not included the suspected (probable as per their definition) cases in the situation report.  On 17 February, they included all the ‘illegal’ confirmations by the NHC.  The WHO now reports cases in China as confirmed and cases from the rest of the world as laboratory confirmed5.

I had requested the Chinese National Health Commission and the WHO to remove this data contamination and investigate the aetiology of these diseases which mimics the virus.  May be there is something in Wuhan, which is more efficient in causing the disease. According to my guesstimate, about 25,000- 30,000 were admitted to hospitals with this mysterious disease.  This may be partly responsible for the higher attack rate and morality rate in Wuhan and the towns surrounding it.   Please read the details of this here and here.

To conclude;

The virus is real, it was not manmade, and its transmissibility is very high in comparison to other disease causing viruses we know of.  Every one of us must take precautions for not getting infected and infecting others.  Having said this, let us realize that the virus is only a part of the story.  As of 29 Feb 2020, 660,000 close contacts of the confirmed cases were placed under quarantine in China.  The total confirmed cases so far are only about a tenth of this.  Exposure to the virus is the underlying cause; but the disease develops only among the immune-challenged people.

VT Padmanabhan is an epidemiologist.  He conducted genetic epidemiological and occupation health studies among people living in high background radiation areas of Kerala, among the workers of the Indian Rare Earths and Gwalior Rayons in Nagda, Madhyapradesh and the survivors of gas leak at the Union Carbide (now DOW chemicals) plant at Bhopal.  E-mail id: [email protected]



Support Countercurrents

Countercurrents is answerable only to our readers. Support honest journalism because we have no PLANET B.
Become a Patron at Patreon

Join Our Newsletter


Join our WhatsApp and Telegram Channels

Get CounterCurrents updates on our WhatsApp and Telegram Channels

Related Posts

My Pandemic in Three Acts

Dealing with the Disease that Never Seems to Leave Town On New Years’ Eve 2019, Americans celebrated the advent of the roaring ‘20s with fireworks and champagne, amid ominous news…

Join Our Newsletter

Annual Subscription

Join Countercurrents Annual Fund Raising Campaign and help us

Latest News