Movements in Orissa
Face Political Repression
By Saswat Pattanayak
11 January, 2007
year ago, on January 2, 2006, I was in Orissa covering the most barbaric
and shameful epoch in the aftermath of Kalinga Nagar incidents. 12 tribals
were murdered by the Orissa state police, because they were protesting
against the illegal, and inhuman encroachment of their sweet little
homes by a profit-mongering private industry giant. As many as 13 industrial
plants had been declared to be set up in Kalinga Nagar itself, resulting
in evacuation of thousands of indigenous people from their own lands,
sans adequate compensations, relocation benefits, education or healthcare
assurances, let alone alternative residences. Countless people were
left in the lurch because one private company got greedier and bought
the conscience of few dozens of political opportunists. And when the
people were told that their villages were going to be leveled --meaning,
their carefully worshiped houses were to be razed off the grounds without
seeking any of their approvals, some tribals thought they should protest.
After all, it was through
constant revolutionary struggles of the common masses, that Orissa had
been wrested from its kings and the colonialists to emerge as the first
independent province formed on linguistic basis in modern India’s
Right to self-determination
has been inherent in Orissa’s history--from the ages of the Kalinga
War to the days of Kalinga Nagar. Just the way, the Kalinga War was
fought with bloodbath, Kalinga Nagar met the similar fate. Entirely
innocent people, yet valiant and brave, unarmed to fight the ancient
and modern emperors, protested for sure, and paid the price.
It has been an annual ritual
in Orissa, economically one of the poorest states of India. Its working
class people doubly oppressed - by the military-industrial nexus of
the government in power, and by the educated and elite section of its
own population that dance to the tunes of opportunism and betray the
poor people's causes.
Despite the odds, when tribals
staged a non-violent protest, the police state, under obligation from
industry pimps, opened fire and murdered them mercilessly. And this,
despite the very fresh memories of killings of tribals in Rayagada done
under the same BJP-BJD regime led by Naveen Patnaik.
Sitting pretty on his father
and Orissa's ex-Chief Minister Biju Patnaik’s land-grabbing anti-people
legacies, Naveen has been the most ruthless curse on a peaceful people.
Enacting personality politics to project Biju as a savior, the current
CM has been turning massive onslaughts on every form of criticism that
exists in the state today, with an inherited arrogance that has rare
parallel. He completes his troika of misfortunes, after Kashipur and
Kalinga Nagar, with his approval of Vedanta Alumina Project at Lanjigarh.
Troika of exploitations
and how they happened:
Kashipur, Kalinga Nagar and Lanjigarh
When Naveen regime sold off
Kashipur to their friends in the Aditya Birla Group and Canadian ALCAN,
they had to struggle quite a bit. Months of endured protests by thousands
of people organized under different banners were not an easy task to
encounter. Along with several activist comrades, I was involved in raising
consciousness about Kashipur and found many people showing solidarity
with the displaced. In late 2000, the protest movements against Birla
Group was gaining consensus among the larger progressive circles. However,
the government committed its first blunder by ordering to shoot the
completely unarmed tribals Abhilas Jhodia, Raghu Jhodia and Damodar
Jhodia in December of that year. Dozens of tribals were critically injured
and shot at. Hundreds were arrested illegally.
Arun Shourie, the infamous
disinvestment minister had set the trend on behalf of BJP to legalize
the most shameful of trades: selling off people's lands to land-grabbers.
Orissa government, the ally of BJP, went one step further. It sold them
at dirt cheap prices so that the kickbacks would at least be good. As
a result, Kashipur project displaced more than 20,000 people with immediate
effect, whereas making mere promises to secure jobs for 1000 people
for 20 years. All bauxite resources were put on ransom in this 4,500-cr
project that involved few top bureaucrats, politicians and the private
industries. They had round tables at Orissa Secretariat and had a feast
on the murdered tribals.
This project, part of Utkal
Alumina International Limited, forced its way in, despite protests,
and widespread discontentment. It even violated the law of land that
denied sale of tribal lands to non-tribals for mining purpose. However,
the project is on, and the lawmakers and their judiciary colleagues
are bedfellows. And unitedly, the ruling class of Orissa bribed by the
industrial houses has conveniently shoved aside the people's demands,
and when needed have shot some commoners to silence.
When it came to Kalinga Nagar,
the government thought better than to tolerate any flak. No demonstrations,
no protests, no opposition - the government decided - it won’t
accept any remaining cannons of political democracy. Shoot on sight,
Naveen’s style of functioning worked with even greater vigor this
time. If democracy meant people's mandate, the politicians thought they
had got the mandate to kill the people. In the most shocking case of
mass murder in the recent history of world, Kalinga Nagar resulted in
deaths of 12 tribals (and subsequent mutilation of their bodies inside
the police station to obstruct post-mortem/identification). All along,
in place of health centers and schools - the most needed facilities
in the tribal districts, the Orissa government had been building police
stations since last four years. Of course the police stations were being
constructed near the project sites, so as to provide protection to the
business barons, while killing some locales here and there.
Beyond descriptions and doubts,
Kalinga Nagar incident was smartly buried. In a plutocracy, the government
works for the rich, and so, Orissa government this time too, made all
paths clear for its partner in crime: TISCO. The Tata venture in Kalinga
Nagar, was done in collaboration with the Orissa Industrial Infrastructure
Development Corporation (IDCO). Of course this deal was as corrupt and
backhanded as possible.
Biju Patnaik was the epitome
of corruption in the post-independent India, and during his last tenure
at office, he had acquired the lands of Kalinga Nagar at the cost of
Rs 35,000 per acre. His son amassed even larger profits by making a
business out of this. He sold the public property to TISCO at Rs 3,50,000
per acre. In return, he paid the people: zilch. Ooops, with some bullets.
But to be fair, the families of those who were killed were offered Rs
50,000 as price of the human life. And the compensation for building
houses: 10 decimal of land!
Of course, the benevolent
Tata loves the power tactics of letting its compliances kill off people
when they protest, and it suits its inroads to further the business.
Same goes with other steel companies that have been also setting up
their firms in the tribal heartlands by evicting the people out, including
Neelachal Ispat Nigam Ltd, Jindal Steels, Mesco Steels etc. All of them
together have been keeping the political circle happy, and vice versa,
in a tradition of tragedies.
The tradition has now extended
to an aluminum refinery near our most current focus, Lanjigarh. Very
similar to Kashipur developments, the Lanjigarh project has already
launched its thumping notes of oppression. The UK-based Sterlite Industries
has been excitedly razing off adivasi villages, including Borobhota,
Kinari, Kothduar, Sindhabahili, and their agricultural fields in Kalahandi
district. In the process, thousands of villagers have been forced to
leave their lands.
But this time, the tactics
of the government - already being heavily criticized for its high-handedness
- are slightly different. It has adopted a two-pronged approach to gain
consensus for the Lanjigarh project. Before we go there, let's assess
what’s the worth of this project.
Vedanta and Capitalistic
Vedanta which sounds Indian,
even Brahminical, is meant to be so. Although based in England, the
company has its eyes set only on former British colony India. Not just
on a country that was being ripped off by the Empire until few decades
back, but also on the poorest state of India. Again, not just on Orissa,
but on the poorest district of Orissa.
Gandhi once said in his Talisman
about how before we take a step, we should think of the welfare of the
poorest of the poor. Now his country has another policy in power: before
you take a step, make sure to trample the poorest of the poor to oblivion.
BJP, the party of domestic
business houses and NRI investors, had this brilliant idea of disinvesting
the existing industries of India which would render millions jobless,
and without backbone to protest the injustices. Worse, they had Lord
Ram legends to divert the people into becoming communalist monsters.
And during those times of Vajpayee, they put BALCO (Bharat Aluminum)
on sale. Sterlite comfortably offered a meager $121 million for it.
Even Balco labor union had no clue that the company was sold out for
this cheap. The union declared strike. Supreme Court of India in its
worst of wisdom had declared strikes as illegal (in a country that gained
independence through strikes of workers as a major force) and Anil Agarwal
got the approval. Again easy. He went ahead and cut off 30% of jobs.
Of course without a problem. One of the largest public trusts was now
BJP, a party that surprised
us all when it splashed every newspaper with full page ads on the very
first term of its election campaign, was always funded by Hindu extremists
living abroad. The proverbial NRIs always looked forward to their bastion
of moneymaking once the command/mixed economy of India took a beating.
And for this, they needed the right wing in India to come to power.
Even for just one term. Because all one needs to sell the country is
During Vajpayee’s regime,
people like Agarwal made fortunes. Not just Balco. Sterlite got its
sweet deals in Hindustan Zinc too - three lead-zinc mines and three
smelters! More job cuts, pay cuts. Less labor force, more work, more
profits. In business texts, they call it efficiency. To us, possibly
it sounds draconic.
Gradually after stabilizing
the sale process of India, Agarwal aimed at Vedanta’s mining operations.
His stake in Vedanta being $1 billion, it attracted attention of London
Stock Exchange, since it happened to be the first Indian mining operation
to be listed there. Not to be outwitted, Agarwal had the face of Australian
mining magnate Brian Gilbertson to certify the resources of Orissa were
good enough. Gilbertson, one of the wealthiest miners in the world,
absolutely amazed by the resources said they were heavily undervalued.
He said they were way better than any international standard and did
not resemble any third world produce.
And so the deal was approved.
It had been already struck. Now, everybody’s a winner. Except
those that rightfully deserved to win. Those that love their little
thatched roofs as much as the bigwigs love their palaces. Those poor
that refuse to give up their collective lands and community rivers as
much as the rich that would guard to their life their safeguarded mansions
and exclusive swimming pools.
Share Your Insights