Police assaulted children and priests with lathis, beaten and molested women belonging to Tribal community as they barged into Juba Catholic Church in Gajapati district in Odisha on 22nd March 2025.
A Fact-Finding Team met a few girls, women and the priests to bring to light the brutalities faced by them.
Introduction:
The eight-member fact-finding team, consisting of seven advocates and a social activist went for a spot visit to Juba, Mohana under Gajapati District in Odisha state on 9th April 2025 to investigate and assess on the alleged incidences of assaults on the Priests and women occurred on 22nd March 2025 at the Church and Residences. The team consisted of Adv Clara D Souza, Gitanjali Senapati, Thomas EA, Kulakant Dandasena, Sujata Jena, Anjali Nayak, Ajaya Kumar Singh & Subal Nayak.
The police raided a nearby village on reports of alleged cultivation of marijuana cultivation. This escalated to tensions & conflict between the people and police; the police retreated back facing resistance. There was seemingly a peace compromise between both parties. Juba village is an entry to the neighbouring villages.
Key Findings:
- Desecrating the Church
The Juba Church was being prepared on 22nd March 2025 for next day’s Sunday Prayers and Mass worship by four young adivasi women from Kondh tribal group; two young women, 20 and 18 years old; and two minors aged 12 years. Police, numbering around 15 personnel, barged into the Catholic Church around 1.30 pm before the young women could sense anything. The aggressive policemen broke the cleaning instruments, and desecrated the sacred space of the Church.
Police entered the Catholic Church premises without a warrant and desecrated the sacred space in violation of art 25– Right to Freedom of Religion, which includes the right to manage religious affairs and violation of sec 298 of BNSS, 2023 – Injuring or defiling a place of worship with intent to insult the religion.
2) Assault, Abuse, molestation of young women
The two young women belonging to Kandh tribal group, were beaten with sticks within the Church and then dragged almost 300 meters away to a police bus, being bused all the way. Seeing this, the two other minor girls ran for their life towards the presbytery. Crying inconsolably, and in shock, the girls asked for help from the Priests who were in their residence within the compound.
Another young woman cook, aged 38 belonging to Sabar tribal group, who was in the Residence came out to the portico hearing the cries of the minor girls and was also beaten badly. Two male police caught hold of her neck and gave a strong blow to the face, tore the kurtis (upper clothes) of the woman pulling at the neck without any concern that they were outraging the modesty of the woman.
It is reported that the adjacent village children, some in the arms of their mothers, were not spared. The children and women were taken in the bus to a distance and left there, filing them to walk the long distance back. A couple of mobile phones were snatched from the women, and are yet to be returned to them.
Beatings and molestation of tribal women occurred in and around the church compound in violation of sec 74 of BNSS – Assault or criminal force to woman with intent to outrage her modesty and violation of art 21 and POCSO Act, 20212 given that minors were involved and in violation of art 15 (3 &4) – Prohibits discrimination and calls for affirmative protection of women and tribal communities.
3) Brutal Assaults on the Two Catholic Priests
After violating the sacred space of the Catholic Church, the police followed the young girls to the Priests’ Residence. Hearing the cries of the children and women, two Catholic Priests had come out from their residence where they had been resting after attending a funeral service in the village. In a flash, a lady police officer attacked the priest with her cane. Fr.JG, age 56 is a native of Pala/ Kottayam in Kerala. He has been working for the development of tribal and dalit communities that inhabited in the hills for last 40 years. Fr.DN, a native of Gajapati district was taken aback at the assault on him by the police. Both priests were dragged in two different directions; being beaten by the police all the way to the police buses some 300 to 400 meters away. The Priests were accused of being “Pakistanis” and converting the people. Fr.DN, who was ordained a priest only three months ago and had joined as assistant priest in the Church., was to celebrate his birthday that day. Fr.DN was grievously injured with a fractured shoulder blade. At one time, he fainted & fell, but was dragged on to the bus.
While the priests were being beaten, the children and women forgot their own trauma and protested to the police as to whether they were beating the religious men. The police then thrashed the cook for speaking up for the priests. Meanwhile, a group of police people entered the presbytery, drank the water; and reportedly took away 40,000 in currency notes from the priests’ residence.
The brutal attack, led by a lady police officer apparently filled with hate, was carried on without concern for human dignity or any sense of respect toward the tribal community, and the states of the priests as religious minorities. Unprovoked assault on unarmed priests within a religious compound in violations of arts 19(1)(a) and (d)– Right to freedom of speech and movement as well as of the Indian Police Act, 1861, Section 23 – Duty of police to prevent offences and maintain decorum.
4) Wife and minor daughter were assaulted in midst of mourning
MM, aged 62 had lost her husband the previous night, and had just returned from the burial ground around 10.00 am; and was mourning along with her family and relatives. At the police assault, her relatives and others ran away; while she and her minor daughter RM, aged 17 years, stayed back. Both of them were beaten with sticks; the police didn’t care that this family had just buried their beloved one, and were in mourning. The widowed mother and her minor daughter were dragged physically while being abused & beaten with the lathis carried by the police to the police bus. Beating and dragging of a grieving widow and her minor daughter in sec 5 of JJ Act, 2015– Punishment for cruelty to child and violation of art 39 (e+f) – Duty of the state to protect children and ensure their development.
5) Assaults on Vulnerable Christians
The team members were told the police forcibly entered and damaged the homes of the residents; approximately 20 motorcycles were destroyed, as TV sets, whole foods supplies including rice, paddy, chickens and eggs, were destroyed.
It was evident that the police were targeting Christians as they also broke and desecrated the status of Jesus and Mary. Destruction of homes, food supplies, desecration of religious icons in violations of art-– Equality before law and equal protection of laws and SCST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, sec 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s), and 3(2)(vii) – Offences of insults and damage to property of Scheduled Tribes.
Our Observations:
Gajapati District is one of the lowest on the Human Development Index; in fact, ranked 27th out of 30 districts. Gajapati is recognised as only one among 30 districts as a minority concentrated district with 38% of Christians. Gajapati is also one of the very few districts that has above 50% tribal population. The violence hit Mohana block is one of the least developed blocks in the district and 2nd largest block in Odisha with 37.11% female literacy rate and 93% people living in rural areas.
As per Census 2011 out of total population, 7% people live in Urban areas while 93% live in the Rural areas. The ST male and female literacy rates are 55.4% and 32.8% respectively
Gajapati district has the population belonging to both socially and religious ethnic minorities; at disadvantages at multiple levels. The district police and the general administration need to introspect itself of its policies/decisions vis addressing the issues of Adivasi, dalit and religious minorities in the district in spirit of constitutional, secular and democratic values.
It is unfortunate that the incidence of this nature has taken place, where innocents suffer at the hands of the police.
1. There are no complaints so far lodged even if it is more than 20 days since brutalities against children and women from tribal communities, and violation of multiple laws
2. There is no information received by the priests on the complaints filed by the priest in Mohana police station as he has not been given any acknowledgement of the complaints. However, it is reported that complaints have also been made to the Superintendent of Police, Gajapati.
3. The grievously injured priest Fr. DN is in a state of shock and trauma along with the senior clergy. The fact that the finding tram could not interview him. There is palpable fear, insecurity and disbelief among the children, women and including the priest as the protectors have turned into perpetrators. This does not sound good for the administration.
4. This is the first time that the catholic priests are being targeted, beaten and paraded while showering lathis and abuses by the police in Odisha known history. This speaks for itself. The blatant violations of Arts 21,25 & 29 of Indian constitution.
5. The team believes it is handiwork of some identified communally biased police personnel towards religious minorities, and / or with a casteist mindset towards tribal groups, and with no sense of human rights and dignity for children and women; even not allowed to mourn the loss of the beloved family members with scant regards to Art 21 (Right to life & liberty, a basic dignity accorded to the dead person)
6. The team could not come across pro-active community and civil society to take note of the incidents of brutalities here and facilitate the victims’ survivors to address the grievances and seeking justice; could be ignorance or trust deficit of statutory bodies like N/OSCPCR, Women Commission, National/Odisha State Human Rights Commission/Scheduled Tribe Commission/National Commission for Minorities, New Delhi
7. Team did not get any report; or even from Media on the brutalities of incidences and attacks on the children & women.
Recommendations for State Administration
1. Identify & take stringent action against criminal elements among the police having communal and caste bias towards women, tribals and religious Minorites. Immediate application of SC/ST (PoA) Act, POCSO Act, applicable sections of BNSS and Fundamental Rights enshrined in the constitution.
2. Activate community policing; recruiting police from diverse backgrounds; grounded them in laws on SC ST Prevention Act, POCSO, Women and Minority protection laws; as well inculcate the spirit of respect for all religious spaces; temples, churches and mosques
3. Train the police with constitutional and secular values & principles to respect marginalised and religious minority communities; respect for all religious traditions & beliefs. Implement Mandatory Human Rights Training for Law Enforcement under National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) protocols.
4. Focus on holistic development programmes and open legal cells to support citizen centric schemes for the region and encourage and facilitate civil society to work along the administration towards truth & reconciliation
5. The state administration should ensure that the police turned into vengeance; The police damaging the house, properties, livelihoods nor rob food supplies and livestock of the poor whose lifetime savings; thus losing trust and credibility among the citizens.
6. Needed interface between law enforcement agencies, district administration and civil/community leaders; whereby trust of the communities restored; development processes fastened
7. Media could play its role in augmenting as watchdog expected in democratic set ups bringing into light of the plight and brutalities.
Conclusion:
The aim of the report is to document and make it public in order to avoid the repeat of such incidents and bring about peace and harmony. The report based on the testimonies narrated by the victims’ survivors, whose names have been withheld.
On behalf of Odisha Lawyers Forum:
- Adv Clara D Souza: [email protected]
- Adv Thomas EA: [email protected]
- Adv Kulakanta D: email: [email protected]
